Lucy Anna (Satterwhite) Echols: Difference between revisions

Lucy Anna (Satterwhite) Echols
	...
Born	July 1, 1821 (Troup County, Georgia)
Died	June 17, 1898
Parents	Obed Satterwhite and ...
Spouse	John Washington Echols
Children	Lucy A. Echols, Nancy A. Echols, Celesctius Echols, Amy Echols, Martha Echols, Josephus Bryan Echols, Mary. J. Echols, John Echols, Franklin Echols

← Older edit Newer edit →

Revision as of 05:29, 11 January 2026

Timeline

The The Gospel Messenger features an obituary for "Mrs. L. A. Echols". An asterisk (*) in the following table indicates the data stems from this obituary.

Date	Event
July 1, 1821	Born to Obed Satterwhite*
October 4, 1838	Married to J. W. Echols*
1847	Joined Primitive Baptist Church in at Mount Hickory*
October 5, 1865	Husband died*
1876	Moved to Butler County, Alabama*
April 3, 1893	Applied for pension ([[]])
June 17, 1898	Died*

Source alignment

The Gospel Messenger Obituary	Military Pension Records
Named "Mrs. L. A. Echols" Married to "J. W. Echols" Husband died on October 5, 1865 Moved to Butler County in 1876 Died June 17, 1898	Named "Lucy A Echols" Married "John W. Echols" Husband died due to service in Confederate States Army (1861 - 1865) Lived in Butler County in 1893 Application for pension on April 3, 1893

@@ Line 30: / Line 30: @@
 | 1876
 | Moved to Butler County, Alabama*
+|-
+| April 3, 1893
+| Applied for pension ([[]])
 |-
 | June 17, 1898
@@ Line 35: / Line 38: @@
 |}
-== Possible Discrepancies ==
+== Source alignment ==
-There is a military pension record for a "Lucy A Echols" in Butler County, Alabama whose husband, named "John W Echols", died as a result of service in the Confederate States Army ([[Military Pension Records 1879–1940, Alabama#Lucy A Echols]]). However, this contradicts with the death date in [[The Gospel Messenger]] obituary of "Mrs. L. A. Echols" who married "J. W. Echols" in Alabama and moved to Butler County. The table below visualizes this conflict:
 {| class="wikitable" style="width:100%;"
@@ Line 46: / Line 47: @@
 * Named "Mrs. L. A. Echols"
 * Married to "J. W. Echols"
-* Moved to Butler County
+* Husband died on October 5, 1865
+* Moved to Butler County in 1876
+* Died June 17, 1898
 |
 * Named "Lucy A Echols"
 * Married "John W. Echols"
+* Husband died due to service in Confederate States Army (1861 - 1865)
+* Lived in Butler County in 1893
+* Application for pension on April 3, 1893
 |}